Here's what I came up with....
I love it! Neatly tucked away in the cabinet!
painters tape or sticky velcro
cut 1 - 12.5 x 9.5 out of laminated fabric (back)
cut 1 - 9 x 9.5 piece out of laminated fabric (front)
Take front piece, fold the top edge over 1/4 inch, toward the back of the fabric. Hold in place with painters tape. Sew using a 1/4 inch seam.
Stack back and front on top of each other, face side up. Sew 1/4 inch seam, starting at the top of the front piece. Sew all three sides, creating a pocket.
Hang your new recipe holder. I used painters tape so it wouldn't damage my cabinet or be permanent. You could also use velcro with the sticky back. Place one piece of velcro on the back of the recipe holder, place the other piece of velcro on the inside of your cabinet.